When I'm not lecturing and students are doing private work, especially writing, I have a hard time justifying why they should not be allowed to listen to their mp3 players quietly. I think at worst, it keep students who might be disruptive, busy. At best, I think that it can be calming, inspirational, fun, and helpful for students. I think there has to be some standards, such as, everyone using their own player, not distracting your neighbor or the class with discussion about or volume of the music, and staying on task. I think with a few ground rules, though, there can be a lot of benefits to allowing it.
I think about my own study habits; I have a coffee shop I do nearly all of my work in. I go to a small chain, so I have a few different options for locations, but I choose this particular one, not because it's closest to my house, but I really like the music it plays. I find it helps me concentrate, yet allows me to feel like I'm not sitting in an isolation chamber. How can I say that students should absolutely not be allowed to listen to music while working, when as a student myself it's a major requirement for productivity?!
I also think it's kind of interesting how much value our culture puts on music and on education separately. They're found to both be inspirational, important, valuable. Yet mixed together, it's the breeding ground for chaos and disorder? To me, it just sounds like nonsense and paranoia.
I think that the non-mp3 player school rule will be a tough one for me to implement in my own classroom.